Giant Daffodil Frightens the Judge
The Fourth Quarterley Competition had an end-of-season jovial atmosphere to it on Tuesday 8th May. A reduced attendance with several members on holiday revealed the down-side of an increasingly retired membership! Our judge, Tony Pioli, had 31 prints and 40 Slides to consider.
Tony chose to judge the entries cold, on the night. This gave members an insight into his thought processes as he considered the pros and cons of each image out loud. On reaching "Daffodil in Situ" he felt it filled too much of the frame, in a threatening manner; and would have preferred a smaller, more manageable, version. He was perturbed that the tree behind the daffodil was also in focus and suspected some jiggery-pokery. As a mere observer it is interesting to note that whereas great artists have no problem with all parts of their paintings being in focus, great photographers apparently must have bits out of focus to prove it is still a photograph! Tony noted that it is often difficult to get the depth required into, for example, a garden scene, and that several images failed because the three dimensional nature of a scene failed to come over in the recorded image.
Inevitably, in considering the images cold, first impressions played an important part. Equally it seems likely that this approach accounted for the high numbers of commendations given.
Tony made the following awards:
Prints: Advanced Pictorial:
Best in Section
Gordon Robson - Morning Gossip, Burano
VHC
Gordon Robson - Liverpool Waterfront
Tony Redford - Lower Falls and River Yosemite & Yellowstone buffalo
Stuart Forbes - Evening Departing Storm
Dorothy Redford - Tuscany Street & Lilies (2)
HC
Dorothy Redford - L'Estroga
Bill Chadband - Root Tree Section
Tony Redford - The Church at Bodie
C
Colin Pickles - Monte Rosa and Gorner Glacier
Graham McIntosh - Roof Top View, Stockport
Prints: Advanced Applied:
Best in Section
Dorothy Redford - Winter Postcards
VHC
Gordon Robson - Lioness In Masai Mara
Bill Chadband - Dog Rose
Tony Redford - Trial Separation
HC
Tony Redford - No Sale
Bill Chadband - Colin Takes a Shower & Caught in Paris
C
Stuart Forbes - Blotto
Gordon Robson - Red Headed Agama
Prints: Advanced Portrait:
Best in Section
Dorothy Redford - Impressed
HC
Graham McIntosh - J.L.
C
Stuart Forbes - Angelique
Gordon Robson - Oriental Lady
Slides: Advanced Pictorial:
Best in Section
Tony Redford - TreeTops
VHC
Frank Hutchinson - Study in Red & Stamens
HC
Kath Anderson - Walk in the Park & Grasmere Lake
Gordon Robson - Santa Maria Della Salute
Graham McIntosh - Spring Trio
C
Graham McIntosh - Welsh View
Dorothy Redford - Cathedral detail Palma
Colin Pickles - Shining Slate
Gordon Robson - Sun and Moon, Venice
Frank Hutchinson - Colours and Curves
Bill Chadband - Swan
Tony Redford - Californian Poppy
Slides: Advanced Portrait:
Best in Section
Gordon Robson - Chinese Poverty
VHC
Tony Redford - Tomb Guard
HC
Stuart Forbes - Jan
C
Dorothy Redford - Street Artist
Slides: Advanced Applied:
Best in section
Gordon Robson - On Guard (Amboseli Nat Pk)
VHC
Colin Pickles - Robin
Gordon Robson - Giraffe (Nairobi Nat Pk)
HC
Frank Hutchinson - Lion Cub at Kill
Bill Chadband - Yellow Breasted Photographer
C
Bill Chadband - A Paul Scarlet Climber
Frank Hutchinson - Hartebeest
Stuart Forbes - Jews Ear Fungus & Garden Spider with Caught Wasp
Graham McIntosh - Lone Bloom & Hoya Tints
Bill Chadband (Competition Sec) |