Projected Digital Image Interclub Competition with Wilmslow Guild

Last year Geraldine Hillmer suggested a new projected digital image interclub competition between Wilmslow Guild PS and ourselves, and undertook that Wilmslow Guild would host the first event. The date of Wednesday 27th February was agreed. Barry Pearson negotiated with Wilmslow Guild and a match based on 30 images per club, not more that three from any one author, was agreed. Our entry was selected and as with the other recent digital image events, Barry ensured that all the images were presented in the required format (different to our own recent competition as Wilmslow’s digital projector has a lower resolution).

A grand total of 17 NCPS members went to Wilmslow resulting in some reduction in the space between chair rows and the import of extra chairs!

Wilmslow’s projection system worked well. All the images appeared clear and bright, and there were no obvious colour problems. The judge recruited by Wilmslow Guild was David Marsh who had ended his term as Immediate Past President of L&CPU on the previous Saturday. In introducing himself, David told us that he had not made the transition to digital and remained a traditional darkroom printer. He made useful comments on the images enlivened by many anecdotes but not all kinds of digital image or presentation appealed to him. In his first run through he marked all but 14 images. In the second stage of his judging he scored these and awarded a maximum 20 mark to the best image of each genre presented.

It was evident even before Wilmslow gained five 20’s that NCPS were to maintain their recent level of success yet again! Whilst the arithmetic was completed, Tony Redford thanked Wilmslow for their hospitality and congratulated them on the smooth organisation of a previously untried event. The final score was announced revealing that we had finished runners-up by a margin of 44 marks. Before leaving, agreement was reached to hold a repeat match as part of our programme next session.

The scores awarded to our images were as follows:

A Stroll in Winter Sun Barry Pearson 14
Approach to Milford Sound Tony Redford 13
Ashness Bridge Colin Pickles 14
Bisti Wilderness Brian Turnbull 12
Buzzard Phil Riley 17
Chilli Peppers Brian Turnbull 10
Cosmos David Hockin 11
Curbar Edge Climber Gordon Robson 18
Curbar Edge, Mist & Tree Gordon Robson 15
Flowers Barry Pearson 13
Hands on Boule Dorothy Redford 14
Herring Gull Calling Alan Saunders 12
Ibis Barry Pearson 13
Little Girl in Kitchen Brian Turnbull 14
Milford Sound Dorothy Redford 19
Mystical Horse Tony Redford 12
Owd Pals Phil Riley 15
Red Barn (2) Dorothy Redford 12
Reflection, Albert Dock Colin Pickles 14
Road Rage (2) Geoff Robinson 12
Sadhu at Pushkar Camel Fair Martin Currie 15
September Thorn Moth Phil Riley 14
Stunt Biker Martin Currie 20
Sun on the Hills at Coombs Karen Heathcoat 13
Tree Tentacles Tony Redford 16
Venetian Dawn Geoff Robinson 15
Watercolours Jonathan Bawden 11
Which Lens shall I Choose? Roy Cheetham 12
Wild Osprey Alan Saunders 18
Wild Red Fox at Rest Alan Saunders 13


Roger Dye

Back